Thanksgiving Gluttony Repentance Post: How to Die to Dairy Queen

Happy belated Thanksgiving my gorged and grateful friends! As I slowly recover from my tryptophan induced coma and wipe the fried turkey residue from the corners of my mouth, a short lament has risen from these Thanksgiving ashes.

Church culture intrigues me. I am always curious as to how inconsistencies or contradictions are birthed in church traditions and cultural Christianity. Alcohol consumption is just one example. Especially in my own tradition (Baptist), abstinence from any alcoholic beverage, no matter the temperance exercised, is a prerequisite for any church leadership position. It is written with permanent ink in the church bylaws. And though this would be another post topic, I can never reconcile how drunk people in John 5 thought Jesus saved the best wine for last if God in the flesh only served up grape juice.

While we strain a gnat out of our wine glasses, one “camel” that is commonly overlooked in cultural churchianity (especially the Southern flavor) is gluttony (Leviticus 19:18). Yes, Thanksgiving is a celebration of faith, family and provisions (as it should be), but is has also become centered around ginormous meals that include ungodly amounts of red meat, lardy gravy, casseroles, sugary pies, and sweet tea. It is a time to brag about caloric intake and the intestinal fortitude it took to force down that last bite of pumpkin crunch.

I ate enough this Thanksgiving to get sick to my stomach for the rest of the night, the ache only subsiding after a couple BC powders and diet cokes.

It’s not just during Thanksgiving.
Look at church leadership. When was the last sermon you heard from the pulpit condemning the sin of gluttony? Even worse, when is the last time you saw a pastor who was clinically obese preaching from the pulpit, a likely persistent indulger in the sin of gluttony?

I’m always reminded of the story about the interaction between CS Lewis and a well-meaning pastor. The Pastor beseeched CS Lewis to quit his unseemly habit of cigar smoking, being it was such a nasty inelegant habit for a Christian leader. Lewis quipped back to the portly pastor, in effect, “When you lose the fifty pounds you need to lose then you can come talk to me about bad habits.”

Many rotund pastors will rail against drugs, sex, and rock & roll without a batting of the eye, all while carrying their idol before the congregation within their size 44 waistband. Since when does treating our body as a temple only have to do with premarital sex and masturbation (1 Cor 6:19-20)? Of course it is wrong to murder, but why is it OK to slowly kill ourselves with our poor lifestyle habits?

It’s not just my Baptist brethren.

No lie: I heard a personal account of one pastor in the apostolic/prophetic movement who was counseling a young single lady who should be considered medically obese. She suggested to the pastor that she felt she needed to lose weight and find a man. The pastor told her, “Don’t worry about that. God is going to grant you supernatural weight loss very soon, and you will find a man soon after that.” (!?!?!) Do huh?

I don’t have time to address all the glaring problems with this miracle “cure” and the irreparable damage it may do to this girl emotionally, physically, and spiritually. Not only is that pastor making an irresponsible and whimsical false promise with no biblical truth in it, he is putting that woman’s very life in danger. Instead of speaking into her life a healthy lifestyle change (and the pitfalls of gluttony), the misguided pastor gave her a quick lightning bolt fix she would rather hear; Supernatural weight loss sounds better to me too than eating broccoli, tuna-fish, and sweating my butt off….

I’m not saying we should elevate gluttony and food excesses above any other vice, just a call to make an honest evaluation as to why we overlook some sins and not others. As with everything, it is not a physical issue but a spiritual issue. Addictions come in all forms, the most subversive types are usually the culturally accepted ones.

Thankfully, the gospel of Jesus Christ heals all addictions.

But as new creatures, if we are called to crucify the flesh (Galatians 2:20), that includes the syrupy sweets and fried fatties we take with gleeful gratitude into our flesh. How would a dead man (or lady) react to the temptation to “super size” or “have it your way” when the opportunity daily presented itself?

To be crucified with Christ in part means the dynamic sway of Dairy Queen has died to us.

To be honest, I don’t like that. Because, after all, Dairy Queen has some really tasty fried onion rings.

Bryan Daniels

Author: Bryan Daniels

I am a follower of Jesus, a husband to Jessica, and a father of three boys: Josiah, Gideon and Judah. I teach high school math as a job, read reformed theology as a hobby, and write this blog just for kicks. With the rest of my time I coach football and track.

5 thoughts on “Thanksgiving Gluttony Repentance Post: How to Die to Dairy Queen”

  1. Its true, there should be no room for gluttony (no pun intended) you should give very little space for it in your lives, in fact none at all. God is kind, He knows his own works better than anyone but we know that not everyone will listen. I will not go under the leadership of any man who will not listen to Him. In fact I have just left a British Baptist church as the leader or pastor refused to accept Solomon as the writer of Ecclesiastes, he is also grossly overweight! The Deacons cant get enough of secular radio and carry course humours. I simply do not want that filth or thier excuses for in my ears. Heretics.

  2. Oh and by the way I do hope that you do not address yourself as the chief of sinners because that would take a revelation from God on a par with the Apostle Paul. And that is not a possibility only with the spiritually vien who are utterly deluded as to their place on earth and in heaven.

  3. It’s interesting that you tie a celebration of God’s goodness and generosity to the sin of gluttony. The implication, intended or not, is that feasts and celebrations are bad. If anything, God’s Word demonstrates that He loves feasts and celebrations.

    1. I’m sorry if that is how you interpreted it Randy. I never said Thanksgiving or celebrative feasts are bad. I said gluttony is bad. Hopefully we can find a way to celebrate and give thanks without feeding our natural bent for excess. Thanksgiving meals simply highlight that excess for many, and that is unfortunate when a celebration of faith and family becomes a time to feed the idol of our belly.

      I find it hard to believe no one else struggles with this (I do) when America is the most obese nation in the world. Paul even warns the Corinthians about making celebrative feasts a time for excess and selfish gain. (1 Cor 6:12-20, 11:17-34 even the Lord’s Supper!) I don’t think Paul was making the implication (as you say) that feasts and celebrations are bad, but simply that sinful mankind has the ability to make all good things bad.

      Thanks for the comment brother, it helps me strive to be more clear! Maybe I should just say: God loves celebrations of thanks, God hates gluttony. Period.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: